Rustic Refuels

The below ranking shows the top independent gas stations across America, as voted for by 3,016 drivers.

RankingGas StationTown/CityState
11 Maw Maw’s Country Market Robertsdale Alabama
12 Peachtree Central Gas Murphy North Carolina
13 The Davis General Leipers Fork Tennessee
14 The Corner Market Roundhill Kentucky
15 Victory Fuel Station Atco New Jersey
16 Tioga Gas Mart & Whoa Nellie Deli Lee Vining California
17 McConnell’s Country Store Waterville Pennsylvania
18 Family Express Indianapolis Indiana
19 J&J Country Roads Store Pence Springs West Virginia
20 Ohana Fuels Hilo Hawaii
21 Country Corner Store & Station Russellville Arkansas
22 Lake Street Station by MJ Crystal Michigan
23 Jesse James Country Store Garretson South Dakota
24 Mt Top Convenience Thomas West Virginia
25 Hruska’s Store & Bakery Ellinger Texas
26 Yellowstone Station Cartwright North Dakota
27 Honor Market Yountville California
28 Arlo’s Country Store & Tavern Union Dale Pennsylvania
29 Cox Family Stores Dublin California
30 The Thumb Scottsdale Arizona
31 Snow’s Family Market Mercer Wisconsin
32 Guy’s Market on 68 New Brighton Pennsylvania
33 Sewee Outpost Awendaw South Carolina
34 Wilson’s Tall Chief Gas Station & Convenience Store Sperry Oklahoma
35 Gas Express Lakewood Colorado
36 Lorida Gas Station Lorida Florida
37 Quik Mart Tucson Arizona
38 The Fill-Er-Up Parkton Maryland
39 Hollow Mountain Gas Station Hanksville Utah
40 Tumbleweed Express Laramie Wyoming
41 Family Grocery & Deli Husser Louisiana
42 Kent & Sue’s Quick Stop Bay St. Louis Mississippi
43 Tonto Basin Marketplace Tonto Basin Arizona
44 CITGO Gibson’s Quik Mart Harvey Illinois
45 Allen Brothers Farm Stand & Irving Gas & Diesel Westminster Vermont
46 Cantrell’s Market Goodlettsville Tennessee
47 Gas Bros Hapeville Georgia
48 Rodeo West Convenience Store Cody Wyoming
49 Clearwater Travel Plaza Clearwater Minnesota
50 Gas Cafe One Stop Crested Butte Colorado
51 Archer Lodge Express Clayton North Carolina
52 Floyd Xpress Market (Floyd Xpress Deli & Gas) Floyd Virginia
53 Wiggins Grocery Danville Alabama
54 Pure Service Station Decatur Georgia
55 Fanwood Gas Fanwood New Jersey
56 McFalls Service Station Boswell Indiana
57 Pacific Gasoline Station Gardnerville Nevada
58 Skinny’s Texaco St. Helens Oregon
59 Coal Mine Gas Express Littleton Colorado
60 Mullenix Market Deli & Espresso Port Orchard Washington
61 Nitty Gritty Gas & Thrift Unadilla Nebraska
62 Astoria Mini Mart East Astoria Oregon
63 Bear’s One Stop Newport Maine
64 Liberty Happy Gas Convenience Store & Deli Magnolia Delaware
65 Papa’s Healthy Food & Fuel East Otis Massachusetts
66 Traveler’s Service Station (“Mustang”) Peñasco New Mexico
67 Michael’s Mini Mart Velarde New Mexico
68 Homestead Convenience Cortland Nebraska
69 Local Gas South Otselic New York
70 Montezuma Gas N Go Montezuma Georgia
71 Napier’s Scottsville Kentucky
72 Simonson Station Stores Park Rapids Minnesota
73 Quilcene Village Store Quilcene Washington
74 Direct to You Gas Westminster Maryland
75 Noble Gas Station East Lyme Connecticut
76 Valley Pump & Casino Wagner South Dakota
77 The Filling Station Ames Iowa
78 Troy General Store Troy Maine
79 Hussey’s General Store Windsor Maine
80 Jakes Place Jordan Montana
81 Lakewood Market Boulder Junction Wisconsin
82 Lee Delauter & Son Myersville and Middletown Maryland
83 Yo Boca Taco! Wayland Massachusetts
84 Casper’s 66 Linn Missouri
85 Garibaldi’s Gas Station Twin Falls Idaho
86 Tillies Mini-Mart Pioche Nevada
87 Y Road General Store Linn Creek Missouri
88 Pops 66 Arcadia Oklahoma
89 A-Mart Express Canton Ohio
90 Perry’s Full Service Columbia Missouri
91 McSheffrey’s Up North Glen New Hampshire
92 Rito Quemado Store Quemado New Mexico
93 Mentone Market Mentone Alabama
94 Bode’s General Store Abiquiú New Mexico
95 Scammon Express & Deli Scammon Kansas
96 Speedy Gas Newark Delaware
97 Basecamp Grocery & Liquor Wilson Wyoming
98 Essential One Anchorage Alaska
99 Sherborn Fuel Sherborn Massachusetts
100 Legacy Markets Shadwell Virginia
101 Pratt’s Store Bridport Vermont
102 State Oil Fuel Center Belle Chasse Louisiana
103 Truckers Inn Sauk Centre Minnesota
104 American Gas Wichita Kansas
105 Belleville Station Belleville Arkansas
106 Bob’s Oil Grand Forks North Dakota
107 Nick’s Gas N Go Lyndonville Vermont
108 Dee’s Super Service Laketown Utah
109 Elliston Store Elliston Montana
110 Brown’s Express Deckerville Michigan
111 Goshen Country Store Goshen New Hampshire
112 Isinglass Country Store Strafford New Hampshire
113 AB Marathon Chicago Illinois
114 Emerald Mini Mart Lincoln Nebraska
115 Shamrock Gas Station Ward Arkansas
116 Shivwits Convenience Store Shivwits Utah
117 Fratesi Grocery & Service Station Leland Mississippi
118 Hagel’s Gas Station Fort Yates North Dakota
119 George’s Gas & Service Tiverton Rhode Island
120 Bricks at Campau Corner Alto Michigan
121 KJ’s Fairview 66 Boise Idaho
122 Fayard’s Biloxi Mississippi
123 Curtis Grocery Florien Louisiana
124 Market 126 Duncombe Iowa
125 Ester Gas Ester Alaska
126 Shout & Sack Vinita Oklahoma

Methodology: This study is based on an online panel survey of 3,016 drivers, conducted to determine their favorite independent gas stations across America. Participants were selected to reflect a balanced mix across age, gender, and geography. To ensure statistical reliability, internal data sources were used to establish population benchmarks, and a two-step process was applied: stratified sampling followed by post-stratification weighting. This ensured the survey results accurately align with the broader U.S. population of drivers. The survey was carried out in September 2025.

Share Embed